Teoria do Caso como Método para a Fundamentação das Decisões Judiciais Criminais

Paulo Bueno de Azevedo

doi:10.19135/revista.consinter.00015.19

Authors

Paulo Bueno de Azevedo Doutor em Direito Penal pela Universidade de São Paulo. Professor de Direito Penal na Faculdade de Direito Santo André (FADISA). Juiz Federal na Seção Judiciária de São Paulo/SP. https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9440-4580

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.19135/revista.consinter.00015.19

Keywords:

Case theory, Criminal Procedure, Judicial decisions

Abstract

This article aims to analyze the potential use of the case theory method to support criminal judicial decisions. Although part of the researched doctrine emphasizes that the theory of the case would be an exclusive tool for the prosecution and defense, never for the judge, it is investigated the hypothesis that, under Brazilian legislation, the requirement of reasoning for judicial decisions favors the use, within of constitutional limits, of the theory of the case in the elaboration of the criminal sentence. The main research method was that of comparative law, highlighting the study of case theory in Spanish-speaking countries that contain legal provisions about it. Such countries were also privileged, due to the fact that they belong to the civil law system, more compatible with the Brazilian one. The national doctrine on the subject was also examined, which is scarcer given the absence of specific legal provision on the theory of the case in the Brazilian Criminal Procedure Code. As a result of the present research, it was concluded that this methodology, despite not being expressed in the law, can be used by the parties and also by the judges, observing, for the latter, the limitations of the accusatory system.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

BADARÓ, Gustavo Henrique, Processo penal, 10. ed. rev., atual. e ampl., São Paulo, Thomson Reuters Brasil, 2022.

BARILLI, Raphael Jorge de Castilho, Teoria do caso e sua aplicação ao processo penal brasileiro, Curitiba, CRV, 2019. DOI: https://doi.org/10.24824/978854443453.6

CARRERO, Wilmer de Jesús Ruiz, RODRIGUEZ, Williams de Jesus Lattuf, La investigación del delito en el derecho penal español: especial referencia a la teoría del caso, Barcelona, Bosch Editor, 2021. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv1tqcwzb

CHORRES, Hesbert Benavente, La aplicación de la teoría del caso y la teoría del delito en el proceso penal acusatorio, Barcelona, Bosch Editor, 2011.

DINAMARCO, Cândido Rangel, A instrumentalidade do processo, 6. ed. rev. e atual., São Paulo, Malheiros, 1998.

FREYRE, Alonso Raúl Peña Cabrera, BETETA, Christian Salas, La teoría del delito y la teoría del caso en el proceso penal, Breña, Instituto Pacífico Editores, 2021.

KIRCHMANN, Julius Hermann von, La jurisprudencia no es ciencia, Traducción de Antonio Truyol y Serra, Madrid, Colección Civitas, 1949.

MORAES, Ana Luisa Zago de, Guia prático de defesa penal de pessoas em situação de vulnerabilidade perante a Justiça Federal, São Paulo, Dialética, 2022. DOI: https://doi.org/10.48021/978-65-252-4367-2

ROSA, Alexandre Morais da, Guia do processo penal estratégico de acordo com a teoria dos jogos e MCDA-C, Florianópolis, EMAIS, 2021.

SILVA, Cesar Higa, Litigación, argumentación, y teoría del caso, Santiago, Olejnik, 2017.

SILVÉRIO JÚNIOR, João Porto, Processo penal fraterno: o dever de fundamentar o provimento acusatório pelo Ministério Público no sistema processual brasileiro, Curitiba, Juruá, 2014.

SOUZA, Luciano Anderson de, Direito penal: parte geral, 3. ed. rev., atual. e ampl., São Paulo, Thomson Reuters Brasil, 2022.